5 Essential Tips to Prepare for Giving Tuesday 2025

Giving Tuesday continues to be one of the most powerful fundraising moments of the year for higher education institutions.

With philanthropic support for colleges and universities rising, and donor expectations rising right alongside it, advancement teams are under pressure to deliver a Giving Tuesday campaign that’s personalized, data-informed, and capable of cutting through the noise.

The good news: you don’t need a massive team or an entirely new playbook to succeed. With the right strategy and the right tools, you can engage donors more meaningfully, increase participation, and strengthen long-term relationships leading into year-end giving.

Here are five actionable ways to prepare now and maximize your impact on December 2, 2025.

1. Set Clear, Trackable Goals Early

A successful Giving Tuesday campaign starts with clarity. Before you build creative assets or schedule outreach, determine the specific outcomes you want to achieve. That might include:

• Growing overall donor participation
• Increasing first-time or lapsed-donor conversions
• Expanding your major gift pipeline
• Inspiring peer-to-peer activity
• Boosting event attendance or volunteer engagement

Using SMART goals—specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and time-bound—keeps your team aligned and gives your supporters something concrete to rally around. The more precise your targets, the easier it is to measure progress and pivot in real time.

Pro Tip: Use Mongoose’s Conversation Intelligence Platform to automate progress updates via text or WhatsApp. Supporters stay energized when they can see live momentum, and automated messaging reduces manual workload for your team.

2. Personalize Every Outreach Touchpoint, at Scale

Across our millions of analyzed higher ed conversations, one pattern is unmistakable: personalization drives results. Alumni and donors are far more likely to engage when messages reflect their interests, history, and relationship with your institution.

But personalized outreach doesn’t have to overwhelm your team.

“We never would have secured that $5,000 check without Mongoose. The ability to respond in real time and make a personal connection turned a casual inquiry into a significant gift.”

Lori Apicella, Director of Engagement, Duke Children’s Development

AI-powered tools like Smart Messages allow you to:

• Tailor messaging to donor preferences and giving history
• Adapt topics and frequency to different audience segments
• Trigger follow-ups based on real-time behavior
• Maintain a human, empathetic tone, even at scale

Donors want to feel seen, appreciated, and connected. Personalized outreach communicates that their contribution, no matter the amount, has real impact.

Pro Tip: Use Mongoose’s CRM integrations to quickly identify new donors, influencers, lapse risk, and high-engagement individuals who need targeted nudges or customized messaging.

3. Mobilize Your Ambassador Network

Your institution already has powerful advocates: students, alumni, volunteers, athletic teams, affinity groups, and campus leaders. Giving Tuesday is the perfect moment to activate them as ambassadors.

Peer-to-peer engagement extends your reach far beyond your owned channels and introduces your campaign to new social circles. Ambassadors help:

• Share the campaign more authentically
• Generate excitement through personal stories
• Recruit new donors
• Drive last-minute participation with urgency

To make your ambassador program effective, give your volunteers everything they need to succeed:

• Pre-written text, email, and social templates
• Custom tracking links
• Simple onboarding instructions
• Real-time progress updates to fuel friendly competition

Pro Tip: Use Mongoose Text to empower ambassadors with fast, mobile-first communication tools they’ll actually use—and that donors respond to.

4. Close the Loop on Every Conversation

Nothing derails donor engagement faster than unanswered messages.

Advancement teams often lose gifts not because donors are unwilling, but because their follow-up questions or responses get buried in inboxes, lost between departments, or accidentally overlooked during peak outreach times.

That’s where Conversation Resolution transforms Giving Tuesday readiness.

Built directly into Mongoose’s Conversation Intelligence Dashboard, it gives advancement teams instant visibility into:

• Resolved conversations
• Responded but unresolved conversations
• Unresolved conversations that need immediate attention

This prevents missed opportunities, especially in the 48 hours surrounding Giving Tuesday, when donors are most active.

Timely follow-up builds trust. It also makes donors feel like they’re talking to a real person who values their participation, not just an automated system.

Pro Tip: Use resolution insights as a coaching tool. Identify where conversations tend to stall and prepare pre-scripted answers or escalations before Giving Tuesday begins.

5. Use Real-Time Insights to Pivot Fast

Donor behavior isn’t static, especially during the intensity of Giving Tuesday. Engagement can spike, drop, or shift by the hour. That’s why real-time data and sentiment insights are essential.

With Mongoose’s AI-driven emotion analysis, teams can quickly understand:

• Which messages spark excitement
• Where donors express hesitation or confusion
• Which segments are dropping off
• Where neutral or low-engagement conversations signal disengagement
• What topics resonate most

These signals help you adjust tone, timing, incentives, or follow-up strategies immediately, before performance declines.

For example:

• If donors express frustration about unclear instructions → revise your CTA.
• If younger alumni respond more to impact stories → spotlight student testimonials.
• If you see a spike in neutral sentiment → cue your stewardship sequence.

When advancement teams can see not just what donors are doing but how they feel, they make better decisions that drive stronger Giving Tuesday performance.

Pro Tip: Pair sentiment insights with automated follow-ups to re-engage donors who stall during the giving process.

Make Giving Tuesday 2025 Your Most Impactful Yet

Giving Tuesday is much more than a 24-hour fundraising sprint; it’s a powerful moment to build relationships, re-engage your community, and set the tone for year-end giving.

By setting clear goals, personalizing your outreach, empowering your ambassadors, ensuring every conversation gets resolved, and acting on real-time insights, your team can deepen donor trust and drive meaningful participation.

And with Mongoose’s Conversation Intelligence Platform, you can do all of this more efficiently, without adding extra manual work to already stretched-thin staff.

“The past few years, we saw a dip in Giving Day performance. But this year, not only did we exceed our goal—we looked at what links were driving donations, and Mongoose texts were the top performers. Mongoose helped us reach our donors in a more personal way, and our results speak for themselves.”

Amanda Dowdle, Director of Annual Campaigns and Development Officer at Presbyterian College

Want to elevate your Giving Tuesday strategy? Book a demo to see how Mongoose can help your advancement team personalize outreach, accelerate results, and build stronger donor relationships.

Author: