What Students Need (and When They Tell You): Top 8 FAQs for Success Teams

Student Success teams support some of the most complex conversations on campus. From academic advising to financial aid, mental health concerns to scheduling logistics, these messages carry emotional weight — and directly influence persistence and student wellbeing.

Across benchmark data, webinar discussions, and platform insights, one truth emerged this year: Students stay engaged when support feels human, clear, and easy to access.

Here are the eight most important Student Success messaging questions institutions asked — and what the data tells us about supporting students more effectively.

FAQ #1: Why do students reply at certain times and ignore others?

Success messaging follows different rhythms than Admissions.

High-engagement times

• 7 AM
• 2 PM
• 6 PM

These reflect pre-class, mid-day breaks, and post-class hours.

Best days

• Sunday
• Wednesday

Lowest-performing days

• Saturday, Monday

Understanding student habits helps teams time nudges for maximum impact.

FAQ #2: What Success topics generate the best responses?

Highest engagement + highest positive sentiment:

• Academic support
• Advising/major planning
• Career + graduation
• Financial aid guidance
• Student services
• Wellness and mental-health-related check-ins and appointment reminders

Students respond positively to help, not reminders.

FAQ #3: Which topics are hardest to resolve?

Low-resolution categories are consistent across the sector:

1. Financial aid
2. Technology issues (logins, portals)
3. Mental health or personal concerns

These issues typically require multiple steps or human escalation — low resolution doesn’t equal low performance; it reflects complexity.

FAQ #4: Why do impersonal messages trigger opt-outs?

Because impersonal often reads as irrelevant.

Benchmarks show:

• Impersonal messages → highest Success opt-out rates (1.3–2.5%)
• Negative messages → not as harmful
• High-need topics → extremely low opt-outs (0.2–1.0%)

Students disengage when messaging feels generic, even if it’s well-intentioned.

FAQ #5: How should Success campaigns be organized inside Mongoose?

Top-performing Success teams use:

1. Clear naming conventions

(FY25_SS_Advising_Aug, etc.)

2. Segmentation based on student lifecycle

• First-year vs. seniors
• At-risk vs. high-performing
• Online vs. on-campus
• Students with incomplete tasks

3. Smart Messages

Smart Messages are perfect for:

• Appointment confirmations
• Weekly check-ins
• Barrier detection
• “Reply A if…” workflows

4. Conversation Resolution

Conversation Resolution is a must-have for spotting dropped or unanswered student needs.

FAQ #6: What underused features should Success teams adopt?

Automations

For:

• After-hours acknowledgments
• Appointment reminders
• Follow-ups
• Re-engagement campaigns

WhatsApp

Especially useful for international or online students.

Performance Insights

Timing and topic trend analytics help streamline support operations.

Smart Message templates

For common advising or financial aid flows.

FAQ #7: How often should Student Success send texts? Will extra check-ins cause opt-outs?

The data is clear:

High-need messages = extremely low opt-outs.

• Mental health: 0.2%
• Financial aid: 1.0%
• Student services: 0.8%

What matters most is relevance, not frequency.

Recommended cadence:

• Weekly check-ins during peak stress periods
• Biweekly nudges otherwise
• Immediate follow-up during advising or financial aid cycles

Supportive check-ins rarely cause drop-off — irrelevant messages do.

FAQ #8: What reports should Success teams track?

Core reports include:

• Conversation Resolution (unanswered questions)
• Performance Insights (timing, reply rates, sentiment)
• Topic Trends (academic, financial, wellness)
• Opt-Out Trends by campaign
• Smart Message branch performance (barrier identification)

These insights help you understand student needs before they escalate.

Student Success messaging is not about volume; it’s about clarity, timing, and empathy.

The institutions that excel are those who combine conversational tone with automation, personalization, and consistent follow-through. When students feel seen, supported, and guided, they stay engaged — and stay enrolled.

Your Year in Conversations

Mongoose customers: Want to know your institution’s most effective message types, topics, and engagement trends? Book time with your Customer Success Manager to see how your conversations have shaped outcomes — and where your greatest opportunities lie ahead.

To learn more about Mongoose, book a demo today.

Author: